Mechanic’s Lien | Pittsburgh Lawyer For Claims & Defenses

---

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a Mechanic's Lien?  

The definition of a mechanics lien is a security interest in the title to property for the benefit of the contractor, sub-contractor, or supplier who improved said property.  A mechanic's lien (sometimes misspelled as "mechanics lien") clouds title to property.

 

Legal Advice - Rely on a Pittsburgh Lawyer, Not a Website   

Firstly, before reading further, realize that this website is no substitute for talking to a lawyer.  An attorney will have the most up-to-date information.  Thus, call today for a free consultation.

 

First, What a Mechanic's Is Not

A mechanics lien is not a money judgment that can be used to execute on a person's assets or force the sale of property.  Plus, obtaining a money judgment requires an action separate action at law.  This can be for a  residential or commercial new construction, or home improvement on the contractor or builder. Additionally, each Pittsburgh lawyer at our firm can help enforce the contract claim or claim for unjust enrichment.   

 

Secondly, Why Obtain a Mechanic's Lien? 

Although a mechanic's lien may lack "teeth," as mentioned, few property owners are OK with their property title being clouded.  As a result, the mere threat of a lien can often provide enough leverage to resolve a dispute.

Secondly, a Pittsburgh lawyer can tell you: a mechanic's lien creates fast leverage for the contractor.  In fact, a mechanic's lien  clouds title to property almost immediately.  Undeniably, this hold  true so long as a notice of intent to obtain a lien is timely served. This is discussed below.  Thus, while the mechanic's lien may be challenged in court, it remain in place until removed by order of court.

 A claim in court for money damages, on the other hand, is separate.  In fact, it has more "teeth" than a mechanic's lien.  However, a lawsuit will have no immediate effect on the Defendant's real property several months (sometimes years) later, until the action results in a money judgment.

 

How Much Does it Cost to Bring or Defend a Mechanic's Lien Action? 

Contact a Pittsburgh lawyer at our firm to learn our reasonable flat fees.  Our Pittsburgh attorneys make it cost effective  for you to hire us.  We will efficiently perfect or defend a mechanic's lien.  In fact, our lawyers also negotiate a resolution, or bring (or defend) a separate action for money damages for breach of contract.

Note: a money judgment (for breach of contract) has more "teeth" than a Mechanic's lien judgment.  This is because a money judgment can be used to garnish assets & accounts.  It can also force the sale of real property to satisfy the judgment.

Those Needing Assistance 

Our lawyers can help with any mechanics lien matter.  In fact, our attorneys regularly assist builders, contractors, subcontractors, and/or supplier, who has not been paid on a job.  Likewise, we also assist property owner.  Perhaps you've received notice of a lien claim, thus, our Pittsburgh lawyers can help.

 

Why Utilize Our Firm?   

Our 7 Pittsburgh attorney firm has had the privilege of representing property owners and contractors.  We handle a wide-ranging construction disputes and mechanic's lien actions throughout Western Pennsylvania.  Moreover, below is a more detailed discussion of the law in this area and the text of the PA mechanic's lien statute.

Why do we do this? We provide this information online as a courtesy.  In fact, our goals is to help property owners (including home and commercial property owners), contractors, subcontractors, and suppliers.

 

Key Issues to Consider For a Mechanic's Lien Claim

How much time do I have?  

Those taking seeking to obtain a mechanic's lien must do so within key deadlines.  The lien must be filed within six (6) months after the goods or services are rendered. Importantly, unlike general contractors, suppliers and subcontractors must also give the property owner formal written notice before taking a lien.  This means, the contractor's Pittsburgh lawyer must serve notice within five months of the work being completed, for the lien to be filed within six months of the goods or services being rendered.

Must the Notice Obey Formalities? 

Yes.  Your notice of lien ( sometimes called, notice of intent to file a lien) must be served properly and contain certain formalities, such as:

First, the name of the contractor, subcontractor, or supplier,

Second, the name of the person with whom the claimant contracted,

Third, the amount of money claimed,

Fourth, the nature and character of labor or materials provided,

Fifth, the date the claimant completed his work and/or supplied the last materials, and

Lastly, a description of the real property,

Know that courts are quick to strike a lien for any technical defect because the party seeking payment has another remedy:  he can sue in court for money damage.

 

What is the Timing of Your Notice? 

The rules are different based on the size of the project.  On jobs involving greater than $1.5 million, if a Notice of Commencement was filed in the State Construction Registry, a Notice Furnishing must be filed through the registry within 45 days of first furnishing labor and materials.  Moreover, on every project, the Notice of intent to lien must be served 30 days before filing a lien.

 

Must Your Court Papers Be Perfect? 

Yes.  After you serve proper notice, where required, you must also file your mechanic's lien claim, which must include the following.  First, the claimant's name and whether he is filing as contractor, subcontractor, or supplier.  Secondly, you need the name and address of the owner.  Third, include the date the claimant completed his work.

Fourth, if the claim is filed by a sub-contractor, the name of the person with whom the claimant contracted and the dates on which the above Notice of Claim was given.  Fifth, also needed is a detailed statement of the kind and character of the labor and materials furnished and the prices charged for each.

Alternatively, if the claim is filed by a contractor pursuant to a contract for an agreed sum, an identification of the contract and a general statement of the kind and character of the labor and materials furnished.  Then, the claim must include two things.  One, it needs the amount claimed to be due.  Secondly, a description of the improvement constructed and the real property subject to the lien is required.

Here, again, the deadlines are strict.  Plus there should not be any technical defects in the documentation or lien may be stricken.  At corrected lien cannot be re-filed once a deadline has passed. For these reasons, it is strongly recommended that you obtain advice from a lawyer in Pittsburgh for assistance.

 

Also Need to Perfect the Lien?

Your Pittsburgh lawyer will have five years to perfect your mechanic's lien by filing a complaint in support of your claim and getting it properly served. 

 

What Are Lien Waivers?

A contract to improve property may include lien waivers where, for example, a contractor may waive the rights of his subcontractors to record liens so long as he gives the subs notice of said waiver before they begin their work.  Plus, notice is typically provided by filing with the department of court records (or prothonotary) copies of the lien waivers.  However,  there are restrictions.

For example, with regard to the development of commercial property, the 2007 Amendments to Pennsylvania's mechanic's lien law did away with lien waivers as against public policy.  Lien waivers remain valid on residential jobs.

 

When Are Payments Due to Subcontractors?

A property owner or contractor will be wise to pay subs directly (rather than money flowing through a GC who may or may not pay his subs) for each portion of the job.  Plus, make each payment contingent on each phase of work passing progress inspections, to reduce reliance on waivers.

What is the Priority of Claims? 

Even with a perfected a mechanic's lien, what happens when there are other claims against the property, or if the property owner files for bankruptcy? The automatic stay of proceedings in bankruptcy does not effect the perfection of mechanic's lien.  However, there are other nuances in this area.  Contact a Pittsburgh lawyer at our firm for more information.

 

What Are the Defense of a Mechanic's Lien Claim? 

Each Western PA lawyer at our firm can handle the defense of a mechanic's lien.  We can advise you about:

• • • • • How to strike off a mechanic's lien via Preliminary Objection.

        • Secondly, how to get the amount of the claim reduced by a set off where, for example, the amount of the lien is reduced for incomplete or defective work, or work in violation of the Home Improvement and Consumer Protection Law (which does not automatically defeat a mechanic's lien), or the Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection law. 

        • Thirdly, issues regarding mechanic's liens in regard to residential construction and/or home improvement, which are disavowed under the 2014 Amendments. 

        • Fourthly, whether the property can bring a counterclaim for money damages against the party bringing the mechanic's lien claim.

        • Fifth, about posting bond or discharge of the lien.

        • Sixth, how to discharge by showing proof of payment.

        • Creative strategies to end not only the mechanic's lien action, but also all other possible disputes between general contractors (GCs), property owners (or renters), subs, suppliers, engineers, architects, and any equity investors or banks that may be involved in residential and commercial projects.

 

What Type of Lawyer Is Needed for a Mechanic's Lien Issue?

The type of lawyer needed in these cases is called "civil litigation," as contrasted from criminal defense, family law, or corporate planning.  Moreover, an experienced Pittsburgh attorney should:

• • • • • review the form contracts and "change orders" that the parties plan to use before major construction or improvements are commenced, and

        • review any lien waiver may not be enforceable.

What's the "Nightmare Scenario" For a Property Owner? 

The "nightmare" scenario for a property owners is where two things happen.  Firstly, the owner pays a general contractor the full price for all the work, but the contractor does not pay his subs who then obtain liens against the property for the amounts not paid to them by the contractor. Secondly, the owner learns the work is substandard, leaving the property owner saddled with liens by sub-contractors.  Making things even worse, the owner may need to sue the contractor and/or subs for damage caused by the incomplete work!

A contractor, on the other hand, needs to make sure the underlying contract protects him from the property owner dealing with subs directly, cutting out the general contractor. Careful planning can avoid these scenarios.

 

What are the Relevant Updates to PA's Mechanic's Lien Law?

The mechanic's lien law (sometimes misspelled "mechanics lien") of PA was updated in 2014. Click here to read about said update which we addressed in the context of new builds.  

What are Particular Updates For New Builds? 

This article is not an exclusive list of all the updates of the law.  One noteworthy updated came by way of Supreme Court option, affirming that the strict deadline of filing and perfecting a mechanic's lien must be followed, ever after the case is in litigation and all parties are aware of the lien in Terra Firma Builders, LLC v. King, 249 A. 3d 976 - Pa: Supreme Court 2021), the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania held:   

In the present appeal, we are concerned with the filing and perfection of a lien, which is governed by Section 502 of the Law; and in any event, a claimant may not obtain judgment on an invalid mechanics' lien. See, e.g., Samango, 75 A.2d at 18 (lien invalid for failing to comply with the Law, thus judgment entered on the lien also invalid); Keely v. Jones, 35 Pa.Super. 642, 645 (1908) ("When the act fixes a date at which, or within which, something is to be done in order to establish a valid claim, substantial conformity will not answer.

There must be compliance with the requirement[.]"); see also Rees, Weaver & Co., 406 A.2d at 565 (Section 502 "provides that the failure to file the affidavit within the prescribed period `shall be sufficient ground for striking off the claim;' and the cases hold that this unequivocal provision is not to be diminished or qualified"). Cf. M & P Management, L.P. v. Williams, 594 Pa. 489, 937 A.2d 398, 398 (2007) (invalid confessed judgment "cannot be made valid through the passage of time"; court must strike void judgment despite debtor's failure to file timely motion to open or strike).

Thus, Terra Firma Builders, LLC v. King stands for the notion that proper notice can be challenged at any time, to strike off a mechanic's lien -- even after the trial on the mechanic's lien has concluded. 

 

What Updates Apply to Residential Construction & Home Improvement?

Another important update occurred in 2014 to Mechanic's Lien Law in PA regarding home improvement and residential homes.  Specifically, for both a residential new built and home improvement, important restrictions now exist.  In the above scenarios, there can be no mechanic's lien buy anyone - neither the GC or any subcontractor or supplier -- so long as the home owner has paid the full contact price to the general contractor.

Call Us Today

412.342.0992

Your Name (required)

Your Email (required)

Phone # and Best Time to Call You

Your Message

Please prove you are human by selecting the house.

Please leave this field empty.

Δ

Additional Updates

Here are the updated requirements for 2023 in terms of perfecting a mechanic's lien, but contact us any time to confirm accuracy. Nothing on this website is a substitute for talking to a lawyer.

2007 and 2014 AMENDMENTS TO THE LAW
The 1963 statute in this area existed with only minor changes until 2007. Contact our lawyers to find out how the 2007 amendments changed the following statute:§ 1101. Short title.
This act shall be known and may be cited as the "Mechanics' Lien Law of 1963 ".

ARTICLE II. DEFINITIONS

§ 1201. Definitions.
The following words, terms and phrases when used in this act shall have the meaning ascribed to them in this section, except where the context clearly indicates a different meaning:

 

1. "Improvement"

This includes any building, structure or other improvement of whatsoever kind or character erected or constructed on land, together with the fixtures and other personal property used in fitting up and equipping the same for the purpose for which it is intended.

4. "Contractor"

This means one who, by contract with the owner, express or implied, erects, constructs, alters or repairs an improvement or any part thereof or furnishes labor, skill or superintendence thereto; or supplies or hauls materials, fixtures, machinery or equipment reasonably necessary for and actually used therein; or any or all of the foregoing, whether as superintendent, builder or materialman.

The term also includes an architect or engineer who, by contract with the owner, express or implied, in addition to the preparation of drawings, specifications and contract documents also superintends or supervises any such erection, construction, alteration or repair.

5. "Subcontractor"

This means one who, by contract with the contractor, express or implied, erects, constructs, alters or repairs an improvement or any part thereof; or furnishes labor, skill or superintendence thereto; or supplies or hauls materials, fixtures, machinery or equipment reasonably necessary for and actually used therein; or any or all of the foregoing, whether as superintendent, builder or materialman. The term does not include an architect or engineer who contracts with a contractor or subcontractor, or a person who contracts with a subcontractor or with a materialman.

6. "Claimant"

means a contractor or subcontractor who has filed or may file a claim under this act for a lien against property.

7. "Materials"

means building materials and supplies of all kinds, and also includes fixtures, machinery and equipment reasonably necessary to and incorporated into the improvement.

8. "Completion of the work"

means performance of the last of the labor or delivery of the last of the materials required by the terms of the claimant's contract or agreement, whichever last occurs.

9. "Labor"

includes the furnishing of skill or superintendence.

10. "Erection and construction"

means the erection and construction of a new improvement or of a substantial addition to an existing improvement or any adaptation of an existing improvement rendering the same fit for a new or distinct use and effecting a material change in the interior or exterior thereof.

11. "Alteration and repair"

means any alteration or repair of an existing improvement which does not constitute erection or construction as defined herein.

12. "Erection, construction, alteration or repair"

includes
(a) Demolition, removal of improvements, excavation, grading, filling, paving and landscaping, when such work is incidental to the erection, construction, alteration or repair;
(b) Initial fitting up and equipping of the improvement with fixtures, machinery and equipment suitable to the purposes for which the erection, construction, alteration or repair was intended; and
(c) Furnishing, excavating for, laying, relaying, stringing and restringing rails, ties, pipes, poles and wires, whether on the property improved or upon other property, in order to supply services to the improvement.

ARTICLE III. RIGHT TO LIEN
§ 1301. Right to lien; amount.
§ 1302. Presumption as to use of materials.
§ 1303. Lien not allowed in certain cases.
§ 1304. Excessive curtilage.
§ 1305. Right to lien in case of noncompletion of work.
§ 1306. Consolidation or apportionment of claims.
§ 1307. Removal or detachment of improvement subject to claim.

 

§ 1301. Right to lien; amount, from Pittsburgh lawyer

Every improvement and the estate or title of the owner in the property shall be subject to a lien, to be perfected as herein provided, for the payment of all debts due by the owner to the contractor or by the contractor to any of his subcontractors for labor or materials furnished in the erection or construction, or the alteration or repair of the improvement, provided that the amount of the claim, other than amounts determined by apportionment under section 306(b) of this act, shall exceed five hundred dollars ($500).

 

§ 1302. Presumption as to use of materials.

Materials for use in or upon an improvement placed on or near the property or delivered to the owner pursuant to a contract shall be presumed to have been used therein in the absence of proof to the contrary.

 

§ 1303. Lien not allowed in certain cases.

(a) Persons Other Than Contractors or Subcontractors. No lien shall be allowed in favor of any person other than a contractor or subcontractor, as defined herein, even though such person furnishes labor or materials to an improvement.

(b) Public Purpose. No lien shall be allowed for labor or materials furnished for a purely public purpose.

(c) Conveyance Prior to Lien. If the property be conveyed in good faith and for a valuable consideration prior to the filing of a claim for alterations or repairs, the lien shall be wholly lost.

(d) Leasehold Premises. No lien shall be allowed against the estate of an owner in fee by reason of any consent given by such owner to a tenant to improve the leased premises unless it shall appear in writing signed by such owner that the erection, construction, alteration or repair was in fact for the immediate use and benefit of the owner.

(e) Security Interests. No lien shall be allowed for that portion of a debt representing the contract price of any materials against which the claimant holds or has claimed a security interest under the Pennsylvania Uniform Commercial Code or to which he has reserved title or the right to reacquire title.

 

§ 1304. Excessive curtilage.

Where an owner objects that a lien has been claimed against more property than should justly be included therein, the court upon petition may, after hearing by deposition or otherwise, limit the boundaries of the property subject to the lien. Failure to raise this objection preliminarily shall not be a waiver of the right to plead the same as a defense thereafter.

Your Pittsburgh lawyer should also consider wavier:

ARTICLE IV. WAIVER OF LIEN; EFFECT OF FILING
§ 1401. Waiver of lien by claimant.

A contractor or subcontractor may waive his right to file a claim by a written instrument signed by him or by any conduct which operates equitably to estop such contractor or subcontractor from filing a claim.

§ 1402. Waiver by contractor; effect on subcontractor.

A written contract between the owner and contractor or a separate written instrument signed by the contractor, which provides that no claim shall be filed by anyone, shall be binding; but the only admissible evidence thereof, as against a subcontractor, shall be proof of actual notice thereof to him before any labor or materials were furnished by him.

Or, he must file proof that such contract or separate written instrument was filed in the office of the prothonotary prior to the commencement of the work upon the ground or within ten (10) days after the execution of the principal contract or not less than ten (10) days prior to the contract with the claimant subcontractor, indexed in the name of the contractor as defendant and the owner as plaintiff and also in the name of the contractor as plaintiff and the owner as defendant.

The only admissible evidence that such a provision has, notwithstanding its filing, been waived in favor of any subcontractor shall be a written agreement to that effect signed by all those who, under the contract, have an adverse interest to the subcontractor's allegation.

 

§ 1403. Release as waiver.

A release signed by the claimant shall not operate as a waiver of the right to file a claim for labor or materials subsequently furnished, unless it shall appear thereby that such was the express intent of the party.

 

§ 1404. Effect of credit or collateral.

The giving of credit or the receipt of evidence of indebtedness or collateral otherwise than as provided in section 303(e) shall not operate to waive the right to file a claim, but where credit is given, no voluntary proceedings shall be taken by the claimant to enforce the lien until the credit period has expired.

 

§ 1405. Right of owner to limit claims to unpaid balance of contract price.

Where there has been no waiver of liens and the claims of subcontractors exceed in the aggregate the unpaid balance of the contract price specified in the contract between the owner and the contractor, then if the subcontractor has actual notice of the total amount of said contract price and of its provisions for the time or times for payment thereof before any labor or materials were furnished by him.

Alternative, the above is satisfied if such contract or the pertinent provisions thereof were filed in the office of the prothonotary in the time and manner provided in section 402, each claim shall, upon application of the owner, be limited to its pro-rata share of the contract price remaining unpaid, or which should have remained unpaid, whichever is greatest in amount at the time notice of intention to file a claim was first given to the owner, such notice inuring to the benefit of all claimants.

 

§ 1407. Contracts not made in good faith; effect.

A contract for the improvement made by the owner with one not intended in good faith to be a contractor shall have no legal effect except as between the parties thereto, even though written, signed and filed as provided herein, but such contractor, as to third parties, shall be treated as the agent of the owner.

 

ARTICLE V. FILING AND PERFECTING CLAIM; DISCHARGE OF LIEN
§ 1501. Notice by subcontractor as condition precedent.
§ 1502. Filing and notice of filing of claim.
§ 1503. Contents of claim.
§ 1504. Amendment of claim.
§ 1505. Procedure for contesting claim; preliminary objections.
§ 1506. Rule to file claim.
§ 1507. Indexing claims, et cetera.
§ 1508. Priority of lien.
§ 1509. Effect of forfeiture of leasehold.
§ 1510. Discharge of lien on payment into court or entry of security.

 

§ 1501. Notice by subcontractor as condition precedent.

(a) Preliminary Notice in Case of Alteration and Repair. First, no claim by a subcontractor for alterations or repairs shall be valid unless, in addition to the formal notice required by subsection (b) of this section, he shall have given to the owner, on or before the date of completion of his work, a written preliminary notice of his intention to file a claim if the amount due or to become due is not paid. The notice need set forth only the name of the subcontractor, the contractor, a general description of the property against which the claim is to be filed, the amount then due or to become due, and a statement of intention to file a claim therefor.

(b) Formal Notice in All Cases by Subcontractor. No claim by a subcontractor, whether for erection or construction or for alterations or repairs, shall be valid unless, at least thirty (30) days before the same is filed, he shall have given to the owner a formal written notice of his intention to file a claim, except that such notice shall not be required where the claim is filed pursuant to a rule to do so as provided by section 506.

 

§ 1508. Priority of lien.

The lien of a claim filed under this act shall take effect and have priority:

(a) In the case of the erection or construction of an improvement, as of the date of the visible commencement upon the ground of the work of erecting or constructing the improvement; and

(b) In the case of the alteration or repair of an improvement, as of the date of the filing of the claim.

 

§ 1509. Effect of forfeiture of leasehold.

The lien of every claim shall bind only the interest of the party named as owner of the property at the time of the contract or acquired subsequently by him.  However, no forfeiture or surrender of a leasehold, or tenancy, whether before or after the filing of the claim, shall operate to prejudice its lien against the fixtures, machinery or other similar property.

 

§ 1510. Discharge of lien on payment into court or entry of security.

(a) Cash Deposit. Any claim filed hereunder shall, upon petition of the owner or any party in interest, be discharged as a lien against the property whenever a sum equal to the amount of the claim shall have been deposited with the court in said proceedings for application to the payment of the amount finally determined to be due.

 

New Number: 412.342.0992

Your Name (required)

Your Email (required)

Phone # and Best Time to Call You

Your Message

Please prove you are human by selecting the key.

Please leave this field empty.

Δ